I'm afraid I didn't care much for this one. As the first in a series of WWII books told from the German point
of view, it sounded interesting. The back cover blurb described it as "devastatingly
accurate," and began with the phrase, "The invasion of Belgium has
begun.”
I don't know about the devastatingly accurate part. It sounded accurate to me but I'm not an expert on this particular history. I've discovered that Gunther Lutz was probably Charles Whiting, who wrote many nonfiction books about WWII. I’ve read a few of those and generally rated them pretty highly. Thus, I can believe the accuracy statement.
I don't know about the devastatingly accurate part. It sounded accurate to me but I'm not an expert on this particular history. I've discovered that Gunther Lutz was probably Charles Whiting, who wrote many nonfiction books about WWII. I’ve read a few of those and generally rated them pretty highly. Thus, I can believe the accuracy statement.
However, the fictional story here was just flat out boring.
It certainly didn't start with the invasion of Belgium. The book is only 186
pages long but we spent the first 125 pages following the paratroopers (Jagers)
through training. There's one exciting scene during the training period, but
that was it. There’s also a sex scene, which was OK and probably done to
provide some “gritty” realism.
After the attack on Belgium actually began, around page 125, it concluded again after about twenty-five pages. The rest of the book was aftermath. The fighting itself was OK, though nothing to write home about. But by the time I got to it I didn't really care. Most of the characters also did not seem very realistic to me, although I liked the two main characters.
After the attack on Belgium actually began, around page 125, it concluded again after about twenty-five pages. The rest of the book was aftermath. The fighting itself was OK, though nothing to write home about. But by the time I got to it I didn't really care. Most of the characters also did not seem very realistic to me, although I liked the two main characters.
I’m sorry to say that I was very disappointed and won't be
reading any more in this series. Whiting also wrote fictional WWII
novels under other pseudonyms, including Leo Kessler, but I’m wary of trying
any of them. I may continue to read his nonfiction but I doubt I’ll be looking at
any of his fiction. At least not right away.
Here’s a quote from the section after the battle in Belgium
began, and after the Jager's glider has crashed in the water. Note that it’s all one sentence.
“However, this mood of optimism was balanced by the
continuing menace of the haphazard machine gun fire as the Belgian fortress troops
continued to rake the mass of wreckage caught in the wing supports and control
wires the shattered glider brought with it, besides turning their attention to
two bodies that were now floating face down in the centre of the canal,
drifting slowly away with the current at the centre of the channel, and pinkly
suffusing the water as they did so.”
I’ll leave you with that. Not exactly compelling action.